0 569 visningar

8 svar

Leccinum in USA no longer edible?

Barbara

5 sep 2010 kl. 14:14

Hello,
Again, please forgive my english.
I ran across an interesting blog from the USA this morning regarding leccinum stating that they may no longer be edible there? This particular article was written last year, but has very recent entries (just from a couple of weeks ago).  Someone from the UK posted about it, too.
So I guess I am concerned that the leccinum here may end up not being edible?
This is the link:
http://leslieland.com/2009/07/wild-mushroom-warning-the-scaber-stalks-leccinum-species-may-no-longer-be-considered-safe/

I hope it is not the case here in Sweden, as we picked more than 3 kilos just yesterday of Tegelsopp ;)

Any opinions of the article would be appreciated, thank you!

0

Karl S

5 sep 2010 kl. 15:35

I wouldn’t pay any attention to all these alarm reports, especially on popular websites. Many people experience adverse effects from allergy,  from to old mushroom stews lying around in a bad fridge, and many other reasons. Until there is a scientific paper with a proper proof to the contrary, I’d treat all Leccinum in Sweden as (and probably in the US) as edible.

0

birgitta

5 sep 2010 kl. 15:45

I read the long article by Bill B which questioned the conclusion that leccinum was to blame in this case - his alternative theory was that the (also eaten by the sick man) presumed Boletus Edulis in fact was a Boletus huronensis, which I know nothing about, but it seems to be considered poisonous.

0

Barbara

5 sep 2010 kl. 16:40

Thank you both for your opinion.
Being a “newbie” mushroom picker, I guess I can be a little..overcautious and hesitant :)
Thanks again!!

0

Irene A

5 sep 2010 kl. 22:48

The red Leccinum species ARE suspected here as well. Be careful and cook them well if you want to eat them.
It’s nothing wrong with being “overcautios”!

0

Barbara

6 sep 2010 kl. 09:07

Hi Irene,
Do you mean “red” as in the cap? The orange colored one’s, often called “brick” colored?
Or a true red?

0

Barbara

6 sep 2010 kl. 09:14

Perhaps “copper brown” would be a better description of what we found this weekend.  Orange/copper brown colored caps, “peppered” stems. Some quite large.
The stems turned blue when cut.  When we fried them, they turned pretty dark/black.

0

Irene A

6 sep 2010 kl. 11:56

Sorry, of course I mean the orange-capped ones (have never seen a pure red Leccinum).
If you want to practice reading norwegian, have a look at this:

http://matportalen.no/artikler/2006/9/rodskrubb_maa_varmebehandles_godt

If you want to take a shortcut, you could always use Google translation.

But the important message there is to cook (boil or fry) these mushrooms thoroughly, total time at least 20 minutes.

0

Barbara

6 sep 2010 kl. 18:07

Thank you so much, Irene.  I appreciate you taking the time to clarify.
I think we will return those mushrooms to the forest and stick to the karljohan’s ;)

Svara på inlägget ovan genom att fylla i formuläret nedan

OBS! Formuläret nedan är till för att svara på frågan i tråden ovan. Håll dig till ämnet och den ursprungliga frågan när du skriver ett svar. SKAPA ETT NYTT INLÄGG om du istället vill ställa en ny fråga eller starta diskussion i ett annat ämne. Olämpliga inlägg som inte följer forumreglerna kan komma att raderas.
Du är inte inloggad, men kan svara på inlägget ovan genom att fylla i formuläret nedan ändå genom att fylla i formuläret nedan. Är du regelbunden besökare på svampguiden kan du skapa ett konto för att slippa fylla i namn och säkerhetsfrågor varje gång du postar ett nytt inlägg. Välkommen att logga in eller skapa nytt konto. Det är gratis!
Välj bild…
Ladda hem Svampguiden till din telefon!
Available in Google Play
Rekommenderat Svampguiden rekommenderar Kaffe.se för dig som vill ha riktigt gott kaffe med dig ut i svampskogen
Ny Version! Svampguiden+ är en ny och uppdaterad app för iPhone och iPad som nu äntligen också finns tillgänglig för dig som har Android!
Svamptork finns att köpa på svamp.se
Identifiera arter med hjälp av kameran i din iPhone